Lesson 12

God's Two Covenants

Objectives:


Imagine this conversation:

I think we ought to offer a lamb next Sunday as a sin offering to God.

We can't do that.
That was in the Old Testament.

You don't believe in the Old Testament?

Sure I believe in the Old Testament but we aren't under that plan any more.

So now we can just pick and choose what parts of the Bible to follow.

Of course not.

Then I'm going out to buy a lamb.

Directions: Answer the questions and do the activities suggested in the Workbook as you are directed by numbers in the text.

1.

God has had different plans by which He has dealt with people in different periods of time. Romans 5:12-21, for example, speaks clearly of three periods of God's dealing with the sin of human beings: "from Adam until Moses," from Moses, when the law came in, to Christ, and then from the time of Christ forward, the time of grace. These are sometimes called the Patriarchal, Mosaic, and Christian Ages. In this lesson, we are particularly interested in clarifying about the Mosaic and Christian Ages because confusion between these often creates problems in dealing with the scriptures. (WBK 1)

If we are in the Christian age, and the Old Testament has been taken away, then why use it at all? If, on the other hand, we look to some of the Old Testament, like the story of creation and the psalms, then why don't we use it all?

2.

First a comparison. We are acquainted with the fact that laws are sometimes changed. Take, for example, the federal tax code. When new tax laws are made, we cannot file our taxes under the previous tax system but must get updated to the new code. Some of the old provisions may still be in effect, but only if they are repeated in the new law and not because they were in the old one.

In the same way, God has sometimes changed His laws and commands for people. We generally understand and accept this with no problem. God told Noah to build an ark, but we understand that command is not for us. God told Israel to build a tabernacle and to worship there in certain ways. We know such a command is not for us. There are, however, some issues that are not quite so easily understood and, so, if we are going to make the right use of scriptures and help others to the right use, we must know how to deal carefully with the question of the covenants.(WBK 2)

3. Read Jeremiah 31:31-34 and Hebrews 8:6-7; 9:16-17 and answer the questions in the Workbook at No. 3.
4. So God gave a covenant or agreement to Israel through Moses and gave a second covenant to Jews and Gentiles together through Christ. The first one began at Mt. Sinai but, because the Israelites broke the covenant, God revoked it to make a new covenant. The second one, which began at the death of Jesus, has better promises because it has a sacrifice that can truly take away sin. The outcome of the second covenant, then, is that God forgives our sins and remembers them no more.
5.

The key question not answered yet, however, is this: Did the first covenant continue in force after the second one began? Failure to answer this question properly creates wide misunderstanding about the will of God for us today. We shall look at several passages that shed light on the answer to this question.

Directions: Look at No. 5 in your Workbook and do the exercise given there. This will help you study some key passages and answer some questions based on these verses. Correct answers to these questions are given below, but don't look until you have studied them for yourself.

When you have answered the questions in the Workbook, look at the verses and comments below.

A. Hebrews 10:9--He takes away the first, that he may establish the second. Thus, the first covenant, the one through Moses, must end so the second one can begin.
B. Romans 7:2-4--Just as a woman cannot rightly marry a second husband until the first husband dies, so Israel, which was joined to the first law, cannot enter into another covenant until the first covenant dies. Since verse 7 indicates that one of the commands in the law that passed away was "Thou shall not covet," it is clear that the ten commandments were included in the law that passed away. Since Gentiles were never married to the law of Moses, it is clear that Paul is here indicating that the Jews, who were married to the law of Moses, must be released from that dying law before they can be joined to another, the law of Christ.
C. 2 Corinthians 3:6 speaks of the "new covenant" of which Christians are ministers. Verse 7 calls the covenant "written and engraved on stones" one which is the "ministration of death" because it commanded death for its violators and had no true means of forgiveness. Verses 11 and 13 speak of that law as one which is "passing away."
D. In Galatians 5:4, Paul speaks very directly to those who have become Christians under the new covenant who then seek to revive their relationship with the old covenant. "You who would be justified by the law are fallen away from Christ." The two are exclusive plans. Since one cannot be under both laws at once, God has "taken away the first so he could establish the second."
E. The New Testament, then, makes it very clear that the old covenant, the one given by Moses at Mt. Sinai, ended at the death of Jesus. God allowed a period of transition for the Jews to allow time for this new covenant to be proclaimed, but, with the destruction of Jerusalem and scattering of the Jews in 70 A.D., He made it impossible for the Jews to keep the Law any more. Their records of who qualifies for a priest are gone and the place for offering sacrifices no longer existed. He clearly did not intend for the old covenant to continue in force after the new one began. Gentiles were never under the old covenant, so these passages about it's being taken away must apply to the Jews. It is very important that we distinguish, then, what was a command or practice that was God's law in the old covenant and what is God's command or practice for those of us under His new covenant.

Directions: In the Workbook at No. 6, draw the chart as directed and place elements described below at the proper place on the chart. Later, a correct chart will appear as something against which to check your work.

6.

To complete this exercise, do the following:

A. Up from the "x" draw a cross large enough to extend between the two letters.
B. Beside the letter "A" but on the left of the cross, write these words, "Covenant of Moses."
C. Beside the letter "B" but on the right of the cross, write these words, "Covenant of Christ."
D.

Now look at the following list and place these items in the proper category (shown on the left) and under the proper covenant.

physical birth

10 commandments

First Day of the Week

unaccompanied singing in worship

spiritual birth

sacrifice of Jesus

Sabbath Day

sacrifice of animals

beginning of the Church

teachings of Jesus and apostles

life of Jesus

instrumental music in worship

conversions in Acts

thief on the cross told he will go to Paradise

Directions: Now look at the completed chart below to check yours for correctness.

Category Covenant of
Moses
Covenant of
Christ
Entrance physical birth spiritual birth
Law 10 commandments teachings of Jesus
and apostles
Special
Day
Sabbath Day First Day of the Week
Sacrifice sacrifice of animals sacrifice of Jesus
Music instrumental music
in worship
unaccompanied singing
in worship
Cases of
Salvation
thief on the cross
told he will go to Paradise
conversions in Acts
Important
Events
life of Jesus beginning of the Church

Directions: Look at the text in No. 7 below and answer the questions at No. 7 in the Workbook.

7.

So what use do we make now of the books of the Old Testament in the Bible? Are they to be discarded? Are they to be ignored? What uses do they have?

A. The Old Testament books are equally inspired by God and remain very useful. While we are no longer under the commandments of the Law of Moses including the 10 commandments, these books are very useful as inspired history. From them we have the divine account of creation, the story of early nations, the record of God's choice of a special people through whom to demonstrate His power to the world and through whom to bring the Savior.
B. Also from these books we have the case studies of many people as God has dealt with them. We learn how things go well when we obey and how they do not go well when we disobey. We learn about great heroes of faith such as Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Ruth, David, Isaiah, Esther and others. Paul said these things were written "for our example" (1 Corinthians 10:6).
C. Through these Old Testament books God made predictions about nations, cities, and peoples that are certified as written hundreds of years before the events came to pass as predicted. These predictions help us to know that God was revealing His will to those who wrote it down.
D. There are many New Testament references to Old Testament passages: people, customs, and places. Studying the Old Testament, then, is a big help in understanding the New Testament. 
E. In the Law of Moses there were elements which anticipated the coming of a new covenant and are considered "types" of which something in the New Covenant is the "anti-type." The sacrificial lamb, for example, is an illustration in advance of the coming of Jesus to be the sacrifice for sins. Recognizing types and anti-types can help us understand the continuity of God's plan. 
F. The recurring theme of the Old Testament is the coming Messiah and His kingdom. There are over fifty predictions about details of the life and teaching of the Messiah--and Jesus fulfilled them all. 
G. Not only does the Old Testament, however, establish the Messiah theme, it also presents many other themes that run throughout scripture: sin, separation, salvation, covenants, and obedience/prosperity. Thus, the Old Testament books establish many of the major themes of the Bible which the New Testament books pick up and develop. 
H. The Old Testament books, then, are very valuable to us and should be studied carefully, not only for helping us to know God and how He works, but also to understand those parts of the New Testament which make reference to things of the Old. (WBK 7) 

8.

There are some particular problems about the use of the Old and New Testaments which need special attention.

A.

Do the books of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John belong with the Old or the New? These books are placed with the New Testament but are written almost entirely about things that happened before the death of Jesus and, thus, before the new covenant went into effect.

1. Under which covenant did Jesus live? He lived and died under the Law of Moses and, therefore, He kept the commandments of that covenant. He took the Passover, worshipped at Jerusalem, and kept the Sabbath Day. While we follow His example in terms of the character of His life, we do not follow His example in obeying the specific law to which He was subject.
2.

Does this mean that the teachings of Jesus recorded in these books are not part of the New Covenant? No. Just as one writes his last will and testament prior to his death and it takes effect when he dies, just so Jesus delivered teachings for the new covenant prior to His death so they could be placed into effect when He died. Occasionally He explains a principle in an old covenant setting, such as "leave your gift before the altar," but, His teachings are for those who would become His followers under the new covenant He would establish.

Some say that Jesus came to teach the Jewish people how the law of Moses was meant to be kept. But why would Jesus spend the three years with His apostles to train them in how to keep a law that was to pass away at His death? Surely He was teaching what we are to follow under the new covenant. In regard to the teachings of the law of Moses, sometimes He carried a teaching into His law as it was in the old covenant. In Matthew 22:37-39, for example, Jesus teaches that the two great commandments of the law were to love God and love your neighbor. These same principles are primary teachings of His new covenant as witnessed in 1 John 4:20-21 and Galatians 5:14. Other old covenant commands, however, Jesus brought into His covenant in a modified state. In Matthew 19:4-9, for example, Jesus says God's law about marriage is to return to its original status rather than continuing the divorce provision allowed under the law of Moses. Still other commands of the old covenant Jesus omitted entirely such as the keeping of the Sabbath Day.

B. Another question sometimes raised is whether Jesus took away just the ceremonial part of the law but not the moral part. In the first place, the Bible makes no such distinction between the ceremonial law and the moral law under the covenant of Moses. Secondly, such distinctions would be futile. Is, for example, keeping the Sabbath a moral command but the command to limit travel on that day just a ceremonial command? Thirdly, the scriptures given above specifically mention that the law being taken away was "written and engraven on stones" and that "Thou shalt not covet" was part of the law that died. While Jesus carried some of the moral principles in the law of Moses across into His law, this does not mean that any part of the law of Moses is still binding. It is all gone. In its place is the "law of liberty" and people today, Jews and Gentiles, are subject to this law.
C. A final word about "the thief on the cross," because he gives such a good illustration of how to apply the principles of this lesson. Some today say they wish to be saved as the thief was. But the thief lived under the law of Moses and was subject to its teachings, not those of the new covenant. Jesus, while on earth, had the power to forgive sins as He chose, but once He died and departed from this earth, salvation is granted only on the basis He has taught, that is, by faith, repentance, and baptism. So, one today who seeks to be saved like the thief was is seeking to go back under the old covenant. All today are subject to the provisions of the new covenant and will be judged on the way they have treated the covenant of Christ.

©1999 Oklahoma Christian University